Ellen Godbey Carson
ellen_godbey_carson

Ellen Godbey Carson

Director

Phone: (808) 524-1800
Fax: (808) 524-4591
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Ellen_Godbey_Carson-LT-400

Chambers_logo_for_Ellen_carson

Download PDF:

o    Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act ("PPACA") and health care reform

o    ERISA, COBRA, and Prepaid Health Care Act issues

o    Healthcare compliance and conflict of interest concerns

o    Medical risk management (seminars, advising, and risk-prevention)

o    Emergency court orders and advising on emergency health care issues

o    Credentialing, peer review, and health care quality improvement issues

o    Medical records confidentiality and HIPAA concerns

o    Electronic health records and security issues

o    Record-keeping practices

o    Health insurance issues

o    Innovative healthcare start-up companies

o    Internal governance, bylaws, and parliamentary issues

o    Administrative law (for matters before state agencies)

o    Certificates of need before SHPDA and licensing by Department of Health

o    Defense of medical malpractice claims

An honors graduate of Harvard Law School and former president of the Hawai`i State Bar, Ellen Godbey Carson is a leading authority on healthcare law and dispute resolution in the state of Hawai`i.

Carson has 30 years of litigation and dispute resolution experience, successfully representing clients in federal and state courts, agency proceedings, arbitration and mediation. Her work has covered a broad variety of complex matters, including healthcare, constitutional, civil rights, environmental, contracts, real property, construction and employment.

Her practice focuses primarily on representing health care providers, hospitals, health plans and innovative health care companies in the regulatory world of healthcare law, including healthcare advice related to risk management, peer review, credentialing, healthcare reform (PPACA), HIPAA, ERISA, COBRA and medical malpractice defense. Her clients have included most of the major health plans and hospital facilities in Hawai`i as well as numerous individual medical providers and healthcare related companies.

Carson is nationally recognized as one of the lead counsel in the class action suit for Americans of Japanese ancestry who were exiled from their homes and imprisoned in racial prison camps by the United States government during World War II. That case resulted in findings of fraud and concealment by the U.S. government in regard to the mass deprivations of civil rights. While judicial relief was ultimately denied, the lawsuit assisted in obtaining a Presidential apology to those imprisoned and Congressional redress payments to those who survived.

Carson also serves as an arbitrator and mediator on a broad variety of legal disputes and has served on the panel of neutrals for numerous arbitration programs. She is a popular speaker and has provided hundreds of presentations in numerous states and nations on issues related to healthcare, women's rights, alternative dispute resolution, and justice and equality issues.

Her commitment and accomplishments have been recognized by both local and national organizations, including the American Bar Association which in 2006 awarded her the Margaret Brent Award, given to only five women each year who have made major contributions toward securing equality for women.

Carson's childhood was spent in the Appalachian mountains of east Tennessee, where she was strongly influenced by acts of racism, sexism and religious intolerance that were too often accepted rather than challenged. Her concern about these injustices inspired her to become a lawyer to improve laws that affect people's lives and dignity.

Awards and Recognitions

  • Best Lawyers in America®
    • 2012 Honolulu Healthcare Law Lawyer of the Year
    • Arbitration (2012)
    • Mediation (2012)
    • Alternative Dispute Resolution (2006-2011)
    • Healthcare Law (2005-present)
    • Commercial Litigation (2011-present)
  • Martindale-Hubbell AV rating (1996-present)
  • Bar Register of Preeminent Women Attorneys (2011)
  • Chambers USA™, Leading Lawyers for Business in Commercial Litigation (2006-present)
  • Benchmark Litigation
    • "Litigation Star" (2008-2011)
  • Super Lawyers™
    • Healthcare (2008-2009, 2011)
  • Honolulu Magazine, Best Lawyers in Hawai`i (2005-present)
  • American Registry: America's Most Honored Professionals (2011)
  • Lawdragon listing of top 3000 attorneys in the United States (2011)
  • American Bar Association Margaret Brent Award for Women Lawyers of Achievement (2006)
  • Hawai`i Women Lawyers - Distinguished Service Award (2001)
  • Hawai`i Lawyers Care - Outstanding Contribution to the Delivery of Legal Services (1996)
  • Hawai`i Foodbank - Na Hoku Malamalama Award (Brightest Star Award) (1996)
  • Hawai`i Women Lawyers - Outstanding Woman Lawyer Award (1992)
  • Hawai`i Women Lawyers - Outstanding Service Award (1991)
  • YWCA - Award for Outstanding Woman Professional in Hawai`i (1990)
  • Hawai`i State Bar Association - Pro Bono Award for Meritorious Community Service (1989)
  • Marquis Who's Who in the World, in America, in American Law, in the West, in American Women, and in Finance and Industry

Representative Cases

William Hohri et al vs. United States of America, 586 F.Supp. 769 (D.D.C. 1984), rev. 782 F.2d 227 (D.C. Cir. 1986), rev. 482 U.S. 64 (1987), 847 F.2d 779 (1988), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 925 (1988), a class action lawsuit for constitutional redress for Japanese Americans deprived of their civil liberties during World War II. The suit assisted in obtaining a Presidential apology to those who were imprisoned and Congressional redress payments.

Hawaii Management Alliance Association v. Insurance Commissioner of the State of Hawai`i, 106 Haw. 21 (2004), successful challenge of the state's mandatory external appeal procedure for benefit disputes, resulting in the Hawai'i Supreme Court holding the law was preempted by ERISA (the Employees Retirement Income Security Act).

Sallee v. Tropic Seas (Haw., 1st Cir. No. 91-3936-1) and United States v. Tropic Seas, 887 F.Supp.. 1347 (D. Haw. 1995), defense of an eviction action combined with a successful counterclaim for family discrimination, resulting in a federal consent order with one of the highest awards nationally at that time for family discrimination.

Locations, Inc. v. Hawai'i Dept. of Labor, 79 Haw. 208 (1995), successful declaratory judgment action establishing that real estate agents are independent contractors so that workers compensation mandates do not apply to them.

Liberty Dialysis-Hawaii LLC v. Rainbow Dialysis LLC (First Circuit Court, Hawaii), obtained certificate of need for new dialysis service in a strongly contested challenge by the sole dialysis provider on Maui, involving multi-day contested case proceeding; currently on appeal.

Suzanne Osgood v. District of Columbia, 567 F.Supp. 1026 (D.D.C. 1983), a prisoner rights/religious freedom lawsuit resulting in a consent order against the Washington, D.C. government requiring respect for the religious freedom of inmates.

Practice Areas

Healthcare
Constitutional Litigation
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Commercial Litigation
General Business Advising

Healthcare 

  • Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act ("PPACA") and health care reform
  • ERISA, COBRA, and Prepaid Health Care Act issues
  • Healthcare compliance and conflict of interest concerns
  • Medical risk management (seminars, advising, and risk-prevention)
  • Emergency court orders and advising on emergency health care issues
  • Credentialing, peer review, and health care quality improvement issues
  • Medical records confidentiality and HIPAA concerns
  • Electronic health records and security issues
  • Record-keeping practices
  • Health insurance issues
  • Innovative healthcare start-up companies
  • Internal governance, bylaws, and parliamentary issues
  • Administrative law (for matters before state agencies)
  • Certificates of need before SHPDA and licensing by Department of Health
  • Defense of medical malpractice claims

Constitutional and Civil Rights Litigation

  • Japanese American redress
  • Gender and racial equality
  • Reproductive rights
  • Sexual orientation (LGBT) equality

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

  • Mediator
  • Arbitrator

Federal and State Courts

General Business Advice

Corporate Governance

  • Contracting
  • Nonprofit organizations

Commercial Litigation

Affiliations and Community Leadership

  • Hawai`i State Bar Association (President 1996)
  • Hawai`i Women Lawyers (President 1989-1990)
  • Hawai`i Justice Foundation (former board member)
  • Hawai`i Supreme Court Disciplinary Board (former member)
  • Hawai`i Women Lawyers (President 1989-1990)
  • Court Annexed Arbitration Program, arbitrator (1st Circuit Court, Hawai`i)
  • Dispute Prevention and Resolution, Inc. (arbitrator)
  • Central Union Church (President of Trustees 1992)
  • Church of the Crossroads (former board member, LGBT equality speaker)
  • District of Columbia Rape Crisis Center (President 1983-1986)
  • Hale Kipa Emergency Youth Shelter (President 1991)
  • Institute for Human Services (President 2000-2002)
  • Sex Abuse Treatment Center (President 1993-1994)
  • Legacy of Life Hawaii (aka Organ Donor Center of Hawai`i) (officer & board member 2003-2012)
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution Section, HSBA (Co-Chair, 2008-2011)
  • National Council on Japanese American Redress (Ronin)

State Bar Admissions

  • Hawai`i
  • District of Columbia (inactive)
  • Maryland (inactive)

Court Admissions

  • U.S. Supreme Court
  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
  • U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia
  • U.S. Court of Claims
  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
  • U.S. District Court for District of Hawai`i
  • U.S. Court of Appeals for Ninth Circuit

Education

  • Harvard Law School (J.D. cum laude, 1980)
  • University of Tennessee (B.A. summa cum laude, 1976)